There are a lot of ways you can scale a workout to make sure you can complete it within a certain time. Sometimes it is about getting work done and sometimes it is to improve a certain exercise that you haven’t quite mastered yet. Let us use the pull up as an example.
Yesterday called for Fran, we all know how horrible that workout can be and how it makes you feel afterwards. If you don’t have the required skill set to complete this workout RX with medium-high intensity you won’t get the same physiological benefits that the rest of the class will and your fitness won’t improve from that workout. In that situation the workout would call for a scaling option that will allow you to keep working hard throughout. The Open has a scaled division which has Jumping pull ups in it so it would be of benefit to you to utilize that exercise to practice jumping pull ups for the Open and still get the physiological response we are after, win/win.
Now, jumping pull ups has a very low resistance requirement because you are of course jumping up so it would not work as a progression to improve your normal bodyweight pull up strength. So, you need to do exercises that will challenge your strength more. You will need to go through increasingly more difficult exercises that challenges your pulling strength starting with ring rows moving to low bar rows and keep increasing the bar until you are using your arms as much as possible and taking your legs out of the equation more and more. From then it gets a bit tricky as we are moving into if a coach is for or against banded pull ups for pulling strength.
My take on it: If a client is able to hang from the bar I would firstly work on getting them to activate the lats as the back muscles are very important in pull ups. Then see if they could possibly do a supine grip pull up (chin up). If they can I wouldn’t use bands to improve their pull up strength but rather do exercise which would strengthen their arms and back in the overhand position. Barbell movements and eccentric reps of a bar. If they don’t even have a chin up I would still do lat activation exercises with them but I would also utilize bands so they get the feeling of the activation coupled with the feeling of pulling themselves up. This has worked with a lot of my members in the past but I know their is not just one way fits all.
I do think there is a place for bands in improving strict pull ups and it would be a mistake to discount them completely. Where I don’t want to see bands being used is for a person who doesn’t have control over their back and shoulder muscles and are therefore continuously yanking on the shoulder joint in an attempt to do kipping pull ups.
I hope this gives you a sense of how you should attack all exercises. Is the goal to improve a specific exercise or is the goal to improve intensity?
Christian
Tuesday 24/1/17
Strength: E2M for 12 min (6 Sets)
1 Hang Squat Clean – 1 Squat Clean – 1 Split Jerk
Build in weight
WOD: For Time:
400m Run
40 KB Swings 24/16kg
400m Run
40 Box Jumps 24/20′
400m Run
40 Burpees
400m Run